The MFWire
Manage Email Alerts | Sponsorships | About MFWire | Who We Are

Subscribe to MFWire.com's News Alerts [click]

Rating:Bigger Isn't Better? Don't Be So Sure Not Rated 0.0 Email Routing List Email & Route  Print Print
Thursday, July 13, 2017

Bigger Isn't Better? Don't Be So Sure

News summary by MFWire's editors

New research pushes back against the idea that scale is a good thing for mutual fund investors. MFWire is skeptical.

Campbell Harvey
Duke University
Professor of Finance

Last month Duke University's Campbell Harvey and Texas A&M University's Yan Liu published a research paper, "Decreasing Returns to Scale, Fund Flows, and Performance." Reuters columnist James Saft picked up on the research, concluding that "size does matter in fund management, and if you are an investor it is not helpful."

Yan Liu
Texas A&M University
Assistant Professor of Finance

Fundsters may want to dig into the full report, available for free downloading at SSRN.com. (As of this morning, 92 people have downloaded the paper so far, and 328 have viewed the abstract.) The researchers focus exclusively on fund performance, from 1991-2011.

It's worth noting that the researchers exclude the smallest funds, those with less than $10 million in total net assets, and growing beyond tiny asset levels is critical for the long-term viability of any fund and fund firm.

It's also worth remembering that, while these researchers focus only on performance and flows, scale at the industry, firm, and fund levels has meaningful non-performance-related impacts on fund investors.

At the fund level, as funds grow bigger they are less likely to be merged into other funds or shut down entirely. That means that the investors in those growing funds are less likely to be forced to switch to a potentially different strategy, PM, or fund firm.

At the firm level (the research only looked at scale by fund and across the industry), as fund firms grow bigger, they are better equipped financially to survive long-term. Bigger firms with more assets and more diverse product offerings are better able to survive tough times, like the 2008 financial crisis. And that translates into better being able to help out the funds they run in times of need. Indeed, while an independent money market specialist, the Reserve, collapsed under the weight of its flagship fund breaking the buck after bad bet during the financial crisis, multiple large fund firms used their own capital to make sure that their money funds weathered the storm. Bigger fund firms are also better able to invest in all kinds of things — customer service, educational materials, websites, research, employee travel — that give their current and prospective fund investor clients and investment advisors more help, access, and information, better equipping them to make good decisions.

At the industry level, more scale has translated into more innovation in a variety of ways. Some of that innovation, like series trusts, has actually helped new players enter and survive without the same scale previously needed. Some of that innovation has led to the growth of new products, like ETFs. And industry scale has provided investors with ever-increasing choice, with bigger fund firms launching more new investments and new players regularly entering the business.

MFWire will leave the analysis of the research from a performance perspective to the experts. But there are significant non-performance benefits from scale that the industry should keep in mind and perhaps trumpet. 

Edited by: Neil Anderson, Managing Editor

Stay ahead of the news ... Sign up for our email alerts now

 Do You Recommend This Story?

Return to Top
 News Archives
2021: Q1
2020: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2019: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2018: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2017: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2016: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2015: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2014: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2013: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2012: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2011: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2010: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2009: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2008: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2007: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2006: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2005: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2004: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2003: Q4Q3Q2Q1
2002: Q4Q3Q2Q1
 Subscribe via RSS:
Add to My Yahoo!
follow us in feedly

  1. MFDF Director Discussion Series - Open Forum via Zoom, January 27
  2. Nicsa webinar - Investment Data Science: A World Outside of Spreadsheets, January 27
  3. MFDF webinar - Post-Election Insights on Regulations and Issues That Affect Mutual Funds, January 28
  4. MMI Executive IQ Webinar: The 2021 Leadership Imperative, January 28
  5. ICI webinar - DOL's Stance on ESG Investments: A Look Ahead to 2021 and Beyond, January 29
  6. MFDF webinar - A New Fair Valuation Framework for Fund Directors, February 3
  7. MFDF Director Discussion Series - Open Forum via Zoom, February 10
  8. ICI webinar - ESG Fund Investing: The 2021 Landscape, February 16
  9. MFDF Director Discussion Series - Open Forum via Zoom (West Coast), February 24
  10. NICSA 2021 Strategic Leadership Forum, Feb 24-26
  11. IDC Foundations for Fund Directors, Mar 1-2
  12. MFDF Director Discussion Series - Open Forum via Zoom (Midwest), March 10
  13. 2021 Virtual Mutual Funds and Investment Management Conference, Mar 15-19
  14. ETFGI Global ETFs Insights Summit - ESG & Active ETF Trends, Mar 24-25
  15. MFDF Director Discussion Series - Open Forum via Zoom, March 24
  16. MFDF Director Discussion Series - Open Forum via Zoom, April 7
  17. ETF.com Awards 2020, April 20
  18. MFDF Director Discussion Series - Open Forum via Zoom (Northeast), April 21
  19. 44th Annual AIMSE Marketing & Sales Conference, May 2-4
  20. MFDF Director Discussion Series - Open Forum via Zoom (Southeast), May 5
  21. ICI 2021 General Membership Meeting - Day 1, May 6
  22. ICI 2021 General Membership Meeting - Day 2, May 13
  23. 2nd annual ETFGI Global ETFs Insights Summit - USA, May 19-20
  24. MFDF Director Discussion Series - Open Forum via Zoom, May 19
  25. ICI 2021 Operations and Technology Conference, May 20
  26. MFDF 2021 Fund Governance & Regulatory Insights Conference, Jun 10-11

©All rights reserved to InvestmentWires, Inc. 1997-2021
14 Wall Street | 20th Floor | New York, NY 10005 | P: 212-331-8968 | F: 212-331-8998
Privacy Policy :: Terms of Use